Andy Burnham has recused himself from deciding the future of the zero emission vehicle (ZEV) mandate, which sets minimum electric car sales targets for carmakers, over a potential conflict of interest involving his wife.
According to senior industry sources, the prime minister has handed responsibility for any changes to Louise Haigh, the first secretary of state. It comes as the Treasury and business department push to cut the 2030 target from 80 to 50 per cent electric, with transport favouring a smaller trim and energy wanting no change.
His wife, Marie-France van Heel, recently stepped back as chief marketing officer of Iduna Infrastructure, parent company of Manchester-based charging network Be.EV. She continues to advise the Be.EV board.
Downing Street refused to comment this weekend, though a spokesman insisted the government was united in its commitment to phasing out new petrol and diesel car sales by 2030.
Whitehall at odds over the 2030 target
Treasury officials are understood to believe 50 per cent is needed to lure overseas carmakers into building future models here, while business secretary Jonathan Reynolds supports the change as pivotal to sustaining automotive jobs.
The Department for Transport, which leads on the targets, believes carmakers’ complaints are overblown and that driver support for the switch is growing. Transport secretary Heidi Alexander is thought to favour nearer 60 per cent, with a government source saying her team is pitching itself as the “honest broker”.
The energy department wants the mandate left alone. Ed Miliband, though no longer energy secretary, has long championed a more radical approach, and his old department still backs the current regime.
Officials from transport, business and energy will meet industry leaders in the coming days to discuss the results of the consultation on adjusting the targets, which closed last week after launching in August.
The mandate began in 2024 requiring 22 per cent of new cars sold to be electric, rising annually to 33 per cent in 2026. Its 80 per cent figure for 2030 coincides with the petrol and diesel ban, leaving hybrids to fill the other 20 per cent.
Carmakers say the rules have cost them £10bn in two years, mostly through heavy EV discounts to avoid a £12,000 per-car penalty. Meanwhile UK plants run by Nissan, Toyota and BMW-owned Mini are below full capacity as legacy western brands grapple with cheaper Chinese imports.
Mike Hawes, chief executive of the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders (SMMT), which has repeatedly flagged the gap between EV demand and the mandate, said: “Demand is growing, but remains well short of mandated targets, which rise steeply over the next two years. Manufacturers cannot continue to make up that shortfall indefinitely by discounting, as cost factors and global events add to the immense pressure, threatening the sector’s ability to attract investment and retain the industrial capability the country needs.”
It is an awkward moment for a prime minister who wants to “reindustrialise” the economy with cars at the heart of it. The sector is the UK’s largest exporter of manufactured goods, generating £110bn in total trade and more than 11 per cent of exports, with 188,000 direct jobs and 830,000 supported.
The EU has already opted for less stringent targets and in effect scrapped its outright petrol and diesel ban. Polestar’s UK boss, by contrast, was quick to urge Burnham not to soften the targets when he took office.
A government spokesperson said: “The government is united in its commitment to the ZEV mandate, and no decisions have been taken.
“We are committed to the phase-out of all new cars relying solely on petrol and diesel engines by 2030, and to 100 per cent of new car and van sales being zero emission by 2035, and our legally binding net zero targets.
“Our consultation on the mandate will not change this, and will ensure we are taking a pragmatic and balanced approach to the ZEV transition.”
